Top Rowing Machines Comparison: WaterRower, Hydrow, and Bluefin Fitness Reviewed

Compare Top Rowing Machines

#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
WaterRower Walnut Rowing MachineWaterRower Walnut Rowing MachineWaterRower M1 Lo Rise Rowing MachineWaterRower M1 Lo RiseHydrow Origin Rowing MachineHydrow Origin Rowing MachineWaterRower M1 HiRise Rowing MachineWaterRower M1 HiRiseBluefin Fitness Blade Aqua W-1Bluefin Fitness Blade Aqua W-1WaterRower Gronk Fitness M1 Hi RiseWaterRower Gronk Fitness M1 Hi Rise
Price$2,023.00$2,049.00$2,195.00$2,149.00$2,139.99$2,149.00
Resistance TypeWaterWaterElectromagnetic DragWaterWaterWater
Monitor TypeS4 BLE MonitorS4 BLE Monitor22″ HD Rotating ScreenSeries 4LCD ConsoleS4 BLE Monitor
Key FeatureHandcrafted, USA MadeSilent Flywheel, Aluminum FrameImmersive Experience, Live WorkoutsReplicates Rowing Feel100% Sustainable AshwoodCommercial Grade

Embark on a transformative fitness journey with water rowing, a full-body, low-impact exercise that invigorates both your body and mind. Experience the soothing sound of rushing water as you engage over 84% of your total muscle mass, building strength and endurance with each stroke. Let’s explore the exceptional world of water rowers and discover which model will unlock your potential.

WaterRower Walnut Rowing Machine with S4 BLE Monitor

The Original Handcrafted Erg Machine for Home Use & Gym

WaterRower Walnut
★★★★★4.5
$2,023.00✓ in stock
  • HANDCRAFTED & BUILT TO LAST: Stylish design combined with ethically sourced materials.
  • MADE IN THE USA: Hand-built in Rhode Island from sustainably managed hardwood forests.
  • SMOOTH RESISTANCE: Water-filled flywheel creates a natural rowing sensation.
  • FULL BODY WORKOUT: Targets legs, core, back, and arms.
  • DIMENSIONS: 82″ L x 20″ H x 22″ W / weight: 103.5 lbs (with water).
82
OVERALL SCORE
SMOOTHNESS
9.0
BUILD QUALITY
8.5
WORKOUT INTENSITY
8.0
DESIGN
8.5
VALUE FOR MONEY
7.5
STORAGE
8.0

PROS

  • Handcrafted and aesthetically pleasing
  • Smooth and natural rowing experience
  • Engages multiple muscle groups
  • Made in the USA with sustainable materials
  • Easy to store

CONS

  • Higher price point

WaterRower M1 Lo Rise Rowing Machine with S4 BLE Monitor

Original Handcrafted Erg Machine for Home Use & Gym

WaterRower M1 LoRise
★★★★★4.6
$2,049.00✓ in stock
  • INFINITELY VARIABLE RESISTANCE: Simulates a boat moving through water.
  • SILENT FLYWHEEL: Soothing sound of rushing water.
  • BALANCED TEAR-DROP HANDLE: Minimizes wrist torque.
  • ERGONOMICALLY CONTOURED SEAT: Provides maximum comfort, user max weight: 700 lbs
  • DIMENSIONS: 87.75″ L x 20″ H x 22.25″ W. Powder coated aluminum frame
85
OVERALL SCORE
COMFORT
9.0
DURABILITY
8.5
NOISE LEVEL
9.5
RESISTANCE
8.0
VALUE FOR MONEY
7.5
DESIGN
8.0

PROS

  • Realistic rowing simulation
  • Quiet operation
  • Comfortable seat
  • Durable aluminum frame

CONS

  • Price may be a barrier for some
  • Large footprint

Hydrow Origin Rowing Machine with Immersive 22″ HD Screen

Live and On-Demand at-Home Workouts, Membership Required

Hydrow Origin
★★★★☆4.4
$2,195.00✓ in stock
  • FULL BODY WORKOUT: Engage more than 86% of muscles.
  • MEMBERSHIP REQUIRED: $44/month for live and on-demand workouts.
  • PERSONALIZED WORKOUTS: Recommendations based on goals and performance.
  • IMMERSIVE EXPERIENCE: 22” HD rotating touchscreen.
  • FOLDABLE: Can be stored upright (Upright Storage Kit sold separately).
88
OVERALL SCORE
IMMERSION
9.5
WORKOUT VARIETY
9.0
INSTRUCTION
9.0
BUILD QUALITY
8.0
VALUE FOR MONEY
7.0
CONVENIENCE
8.5

PROS

  • Engaging and immersive workouts
  • Personalized training experience
  • Foldable design for easy storage

CONS

  • Requires a monthly membership
  • Higher upfront cost

WaterRower M1 HiRise Rowing Machine

Handcrafted Rowing Machine with Water Flywheel

WaterRower M1 HiRise
★★★★☆4.3
$2,149.00✓ in stock
  • WATER FLYWHEEL: Replicates actual rowing feel.
  • SERIES 4 MONITOR: Tracks workout intensity, stroke rate, heart rate, and more.
  • STORAGE: Stores upright.
  • DIMENSIONS: 84 x 30 x 22 inches (W x H x D).
  • WEIGHT: 200 pounds with water.
80
OVERALL SCORE
REALISM
8.5
MONITORING
8.0
DURABILITY
8.0
STORAGE
7.5
VALUE FOR MONEY
7.0
DESIGN
8.0

PROS

  • Authentic rowing experience
  • Tracks key workout metrics
  • Stores upright to save space

CONS

  • Heavier than some other models

Bluefin Fitness Blade Aqua W-1 | Water Resistance Rowing Machine

100% Sustainable American Ashwood | Foldable Home Gym Equipment

Bluefin Fitness Blade Aqua W-1
★★★★☆4.2
$2,139.99✓ in stock
  • WATER RESISTANCE POWER: Dual Chamber Tank system & user adjustable resistance.
  • 100% SUSTAINABILITY: Authentic American Ashwood.
  • FREE 12 MONTH WARRANTY: Commitment to customers.
  • KINOMAP APP INTEGRATION: Thousands of training videos.
  • FITNESS ACCESSORIES: Foldable with built in ‘lift and fold’ system.
83
OVERALL SCORE
RESISTANCE
8.5
SUSTAINABILITY
9.0
FEATURES
8.0
APP INTEGRATION
8.0
VALUE FOR MONEY
7.5
STORAGE
8.0

PROS

  • Realistic water resistance
  • Sustainable materials
  • Foldable design for storage
  • Kinomap app integration

CONS

  • May require Kinomap subscription

WaterRower Gronk Fitness M1 Hi Rise Water Rowing Machine

Limited Edition Low Impact Cardio Workout Machine

WaterRower Gronk Fitness M1
★★★★☆4.7
$2,149.00✓ in stock
  • GRONK’D EDITION: Commercial grade water rower with Aluminum frame jacked up with a high rise kit, enlarged handle and pedals.
  • FULL BODY LOW IMPACT CARDIO: Features a “water flywheel” which eliminates joint discomfort or pain.
  • BURN FAT & BUILD MUSCLE: Targets all your major muscle groups.
  • WATERROWER S4 PERFORMANCE MONITOR: Displays stroke, intensity, time and distance.
  • DURABILITY: Covered by a 1-year warranty.
87
OVERALL SCORE
BUILD QUALITY
9.0
COMFORT
8.5
WORKOUT INTENSITY
8.5
JOINT FRIENDLY
9.0
VALUE FOR MONEY
7.5
MONITORING
8.0

PROS

  • Durable and built to last
  • Joint-friendly workout
  • Full body engagement

CONS

  • Can be expensive

Choosing the perfect water rower is a personal journey, but by understanding the unique features, pros, and cons of each model, you can confidently select the one that aligns perfectly with your fitness aspirations. Embrace the challenge, immerse yourself in the rhythmic motion, and unlock a healthier, stronger, and more inspired version of yourself!

1
Promo Image 1

WaterRower Walnut Rowing Machine with S4 BLE Monitor | USA Made Water Rower | Original Handcrafted Erg Machine for Home Use & Gym | Best Warranty

The Original Waterrower – Handcrafted and Built to Last: Designed in the mid ’80s by Yale and US National Team Rower John Duke. WaterRower continues to combine stylish design, handcrafted workmanship, our unique WaterFlywheel resistance and ethically sourced materials create the world’s finest rowing simulator

Price: $2,023.00

WaterRower
2
Promo Image 2

WaterRower M1 Lo Rise Rowing Machine with S4 BLE Monitor | USA Made | Original Handcrafted Erg Machine for Home Use & Gym | Best Warranty

Infinitely Variable Resistance – The benefit of a water resistance rower is that it most closely simulates a boat moving through water.

Price: $2,049.00

WaterRower
3
Promo Image 3

Hydrow Origin Rowing Machine with Immersive 22″ HD Rotating Screen – Stows Upright | Live and On-Demand at-Home Workouts, Membership Required

Work more muscles in less time. The Origin rowing machine builds strength for the long term with low-impact workouts. In just one 20-minute workout on this at-home row machine, engage more than 86% of muscles.

Price: $2,195.00

Hydrow
4
Promo Image 4

WaterRower M1 HiRise Rowing Machine

Handcrafted rowing machine with “water flywheel” that replicates actual rowing feel Flywheel sits in enclosed water tank to provide smooth, quiet, self-regulated resistance Series 4 performance monitor tracks workout intensity, stroke rate, heart rate, and more

Price: $2,149.00

WaterRower
5
Promo Image 5

Bluefin Fitness Blade Aqua W-1 | Water Resistance Powered Rowing Machine | 100% Sustainable American Ashwood | Foldable Home Gym Equipment | LCD Console | Kinomap App Integration

WATER RESISTANCE POWER – Experience a realistic workout with the Blade Aqua’s water resistance power. The Dual Chamber Tank system & user adjustable resistance will have you rowing as if you were actually navigating the waters.

Price: $2,139.99

Bluefin Fitness
6
Promo Image 6

WaterRower Gronk Fitness M1 Hi Rise Water Rowing Machine with S4 BLE Monitor | Limited Edition Low Impact Cardio Workout Machine | Commercial Grade Water Rowing

GET GRONK’D – Gronk Fitness has teamed up with WaterRower to design this one of a kind M1 Gronk Champion Rowing Machine. This commercial grade water rower has a durable Aluminum frame jacked up with a high rise kit, enlarged handle and pedals. **Product ships in 2 boxes**

Price: $2,149.00

WaterRower